Susan Smith seeks parole again 32 years after drowning her two sons

Nearly 32 years after a shocking, high-profile child murder case stunned the U.S. state of South Carolina, 55-year-old Susan Smith is once again pleading for early release from prison, appearing before the state’s Board of Probation, Parole and Pardon Services for her second parole eligibility hearing. Smith was formally convicted of murder in 1994, for a horrific sequence of events where she strapped her two young sons – 3-year-old Michael and 1-year-old Alex – into their car seats, allowed her vehicle to drift into a local lake, and left the boys to drown. In the immediate aftermath of the killings, Smith fabricated a false public story that an unknown carjacker had stolen her vehicle with the children still inside, making tearful televised pleas for their safe return even as the boys’ bodies remained submerged in the nearby water. She later confessed to orchestrating the entire act, following a lengthy law enforcement investigation that unraveled her lie. During her 2024 debut parole hearing, Smith delivered a tearful apology to the seven-member parole panel, stating “I know what I did was horrible, and I would give anything so I could change it.” Her legal defense teams have consistently argued that she suffered an acute, severe mental breakdown at the time of the offense, and that her original intent had been to die alongside her sons before she abandoned the vehicle at the final moment. Prosecutors from the original 1995 trial, however, presented evidence that Smith planned the murders after a man she was romantically involved with told her he would not pursue a long-term relationship as long as she had young children. Her first bid for parole was rejected unanimously by the full seven-person board last year, with strong pushback from multiple parties. David Smith, the biological father of the two slain boys, has publicly reaffirmed his unwavering opposition to Susan Smith’s release, telling the 2024 panel that 30 years of prison time equates to only 15 years of sentence for each murdered child – a penalty he dismissed as far too lenient for the deliberate killing of her own offspring. The lead prosecutor from the original trial also submitted testimony urging the board to keep Smith incarcerated for the full extent of her sentence. Per South Carolina’s sentencing rules in place at the time of her conviction, Smith became eligible to request parole once she had served 30 years behind bars, and is permitted to file a new application every two years if her request is denied. To win release at this latest hearing, she must secure a two-thirds majority vote in her favor from the sitting board members. Parole is a conditional early release mechanism used across many U.S. correctional systems, allowing eligible incarcerated people to serve the remainder of their court-ordered sentences under supervised community monitoring rather than in a prison facility.