Fractured US foreign policy elite takes stock of the Trump era

Following the 2026 U.S. midterm elections, Vice President JD Vance publicly attributed the underperformance of the incumbent administration’s ticket directly to widespread public frustration over the ongoing Iran war. Vance emphasized that household affordability was the defining priority for most voters, noting that the conflict had driven sharp spikes in global fuel costs and broader domestic inflation that had eroded ordinary Americans’ purchasing power. Pre-election polling data corroborated this voter sentiment, showing nearly two-thirds of the U.S. public disapproved of President Donald Trump’s overall foreign policy track record. To measure how the nation’s foreign policy leadership class aligned with these public concerns, researchers from the University of Texas at Austin partnered with the Chicago Council on Global Affairs to field a comprehensive survey of 449 leading U.S. foreign policy experts drawn from the executive branch, Capitol Hill think tanks, industry advocacy groups, mainstream media outlets, and academic institutions. The perspectives of this cohort carry outsized weight: as the U.S. grapples with winding down the Iran war and mitigating the cascading economic fallout of sweeping national tariff policies, these experts will be tasked with crafting actionable solutions, and many are already positioned to advise 2028 presidential campaigns as the next election cycle begins to take shape. The survey uncovered striking points of bipartisan consensus first: 93% of all respondents, including 83% of Republican experts, 98% of Democratic experts, and 90% of independent experts, agreed that the U.S. must maintain an active, engaged role in global affairs. More than 70% of Democratic respondents and over 80% of Republican and independent respondents recognized military power as a core pillar of U.S. global influence, while over 90% of experts across all partisan affiliations agreed that economic strength is equally critical to sustaining American global leadership, with near-universal bipartisan support for upholding NATO commitments and deploying U.S. military force to defend European allies in the event of an attack. Beneath these points of broad agreement, however, deep partisan rifts emerged on the most contentious recent policy decisions. On the question of the 2025 decision to launch military operations in Iran, 98% of Democratic experts and 73% of independent experts said the war was the wrong choice, while 58% of Republican foreign policy leaders defended the decision as justified. While respondents across party lines acknowledged that broad tariff measures would raise consumer costs for U.S. households, opinions on their net economic impact were sharply split: 100% of Democratic experts and 81% of independent experts said the tariffs were harmful to the U.S. economy, while 53% of Republican experts argued they delivered net benefits for American workers and industry. These gaps extended to core philosophical questions about how the U.S. should advance its national interests, particularly in light of the Trump administration’s America First agenda, which prioritized domestic economic priorities over longstanding international alliances and multilateral agreements. The administration has deployed coercive tactics ranging from sweeping tariffs targeting both strategic rivals like China and traditional allies across Europe and Asia, to open overtures about territorial expansion including proposals to acquire Greenland and even absorb Canada as the 51st U.S. state, alongside military actions including the intervention in Iran, operations to remove Venezuela’s head of state, and interdiction strikes on suspected drug-running vessels in the Caribbean. When asked whether it was more important for the U.S. to be feared or admired on the global stage to advance its foreign policy goals, 62% of Republican experts prioritized projecting fear, while 97% of Democratic respondents and 81% of independent experts said earning global admiration was the far more effective strategy. On the question of whether other nations could push back against U.S. coercive tactics, 39% of Republican experts argued that most countries had no choice but to accept U.S. dictates, a position shared by 0% of Democratic respondents and only 11% of independents. A 54% majority of independent experts, 55% of Democratic experts, and 48% of Republican experts agreed that while many countries might acquiesce to U.S. pressure in the short term, they would gradually distance themselves from the U.S.-led global order over time. Meanwhile, 44% of Democratic experts and 35% of independent experts said nations already had viable short and long-term pathways to actively resist U.S. coercion, a view held by just 13% of Republican respondents. The survey’s authors note that these deep partisan cleavages over the foundations of U.S. global power mean a full return to the traditional pre-Trump internationalist consensus is no longer feasible, after years of the administration’s coercive policies have inflicted lasting damage on the existing global rules-based order. They argue the current moment presents a rare opportunity for cross-partisan dialogue to develop a new, sustainable framework for U.S. global engagement that can unify both policy experts and the broader American public ahead of the 2028 presidential election. The research was led by Joshua Busby, professor of public affairs at the University of Texas at Austin, Jonathan Monten, lecturer in political science and director of the International Public Policy Program at UCL, and Jordan Tama, professor at American University’s School of International Service.