Former US Palestine Action activists risk contempt of court over refusal to testify before Grand Jury

Two former U.S.-based Palestine Action activists, Sophie Ross and Bridget Shergalis, face up to 18 months of federal prison time after defying FBI-issued grand jury subpoenas at a closed proceeding in New Hampshire on Wednesday, choosing to assert their Fifth Amendment right to silence rather than provide testimony to federal prosecutors. The pair, who previously served 60-day misdemeanour sentences for their role in a November 2023 protest targeting Israeli weapons manufacturer Elbit Systems’ Merrimack, New Hampshire facility, stated their refusal to cooperate is rooted in moral opposition to what they describe as efforts to target movement supporters and enable what they call the ongoing genocide in Gaza. The underlying grand jury investigation remains largely undisclosed by the FBI, which has not publicly named a formal defendant or outlined specific charges, though multiple independent reports indicate the probe is tied to Fergie Chambers, a left-wing millionaire donor currently detained in Spain pending a U.S. extradition request. Spanish legal representatives for Chambers confirmed earlier this month that the U.S. extradition application is based on a criminal complaint signed by a single FBI agent, rather than a pre-existing grand jury indictment – an unusual procedural step that U.S. outlet The Intercept noted is explicitly designed to secure a new indictment via the ongoing New Hampshire grand jury process. Following their Wednesday appearance, Ross and Shergalis were permitted to leave the courthouse, but have been notified they will hear from prosecutors imminently as authorities consider contempt of court proceedings to compel their testimony. Their legal counsel, Kira Kelley, emphasized the deeply one-sided, secretive nature of U.S. federal grand jury proceedings: panels of 16 to 23 civilian members meet behind closed doors with no judge present, targets of investigations and their legal teams are not permitted to attend, and witnesses are barred from bringing their own lawyers into the hearing room, leaving no one present to advocate for witness rights or push back against potentially biased evidence presentation. Kelley drew parallels to a prior case involving anti-ICE protesters dubbed the “Broadview Six,” where court transcripts later exposed prosecutorial misconduct in the form of improper efforts to sway grand jury members. She also noted that the Trump administration’s 2025 National Security Presidential Memorandum-7, which reclassifies anti-fascist activism as potential domestic terrorism and directs the FBI to prioritize related investigations, has expanded the scope of political activity being criminalized in the U.S., justifying broader invocation of Fifth Amendment protections for targeted activists. Both Ross and Shergalis are signatories to the newly launched NSPM-7 Defendants Union pledge, a collective activist initiative that commits signatories to refuse cooperation with law enforcement, reject plea deals that require denouncing other movement members, and access shared legal and media support resources. The two women shared that during their prior 2023 Elbit protest case, they faced initial felony charges carrying multi-decade potential sentences, were placed under non-association orders that barred them from coordinating with each other or discussing the repeated cooperation deals prosecutors offered them, and ultimately rejected all deals to accept 60-day misdemeanour sentences. They stated their refusal to testify before the grand jury was an unambiguous, pre-determined choice rather than a difficult deliberation, aimed at protecting not only the unannounced target of the current probe but all members of their activist networks from overreach. The U.S. Department of Justice declined to issue any comment on the ongoing case when contacted by Middle East Eye.