分类: society

  • Man shot dead in County Dublin

    Man shot dead in County Dublin

    A fatal shooting that has left a tight-knit suburban Dublin community reeling has claimed the life of a man in his 40s, in an incident that unfolded early Sunday morning in Dún Laoghaire, County Dublin.

    According to official and local reports, the shooting took place at approximately 8:30 a.m. local time at Patrician Park, located off Kill Avenue. Irish national broadcaster RTÉ has confirmed that the victim’s body has already been transported from the crime scene for further processing.

    The Gardaí, Ireland’s national police service, has announced that a post-mortem examination, which will determine the official cause of death and other critical forensic details, will be scheduled at an appropriate upcoming time. Law enforcement has issued a public appeal, urging any members of the public who were in the area around the time of the incident, or who hold any information that could assist the investigation, to contact authorities immediately.

    In response to the ongoing investigation, multiple road closures have been put in place across the area, affecting key routes including Kill Avenue and Glenageary Road Upper. Local transportation officials have implemented detour routes to redirect vehicle traffic away from the restricted crime scene zone.

    Local elected representatives and residents have spoken of their deep shock at the violent incident, which is unprecedented in the quiet, community-focused area. Thomas Joseph, a local councillor with the Irish Labour Party, described the mood among residents as one of widespread fear and disbelief in comments to RTÉ.

    “It’s quite unfortunate. I haven’t seen anything like this before, and people are shocked and scared,” Joseph said. “People are living very peacefully, and especially in this area, [there are] very community-oriented people talking to each other, but obviously, this is my first time hearing something like this it’s a big shock.”

    The sentiment of stunned surprise was echoed by local resident Anthony Byrne, who told reporters that the shooting was entirely out of character for the neighborhood. “It’s very strange. I can’t remember anything like this before, first time I’ve seen anything like this,” Byrne said.

    As of Monday morning, the Gardaí have not released any further details about potential suspects, the motive for the shooting, or updates on the progress of the investigation.

  • Three men die in separate weekend crashes in the Republic

    Three men die in separate weekend crashes in the Republic

    Three people have lost their lives in three distinct road traffic incidents that unfolded across three counties in the Republic of Ireland on Saturday, Irish national police service Gardaí has confirmed. All three fatal crashes occurred within a 10-hour window across the country’s northern, southern and central regions.

    The first fatal collision was reported at 10:45 local time in Killick, Kilcock, County Kildare. A motorcyclist in his 50s was killed when his vehicle crashed alone, with no other vehicles involved in the incident.

    Shortly before 20:00 local time, a second fatal crash took place on the N20 roadway at Castlewrixon near Ballyhea, County Cork. In this incident, a motorcyclist in his 30s collided head-on with a jeep. The 80-year-old man operating the jeep was transported to a local hospital for medical assessment, though officials confirmed his injuries are not considered life-threatening.

    The third fatal accident occurred just over an hour later at 21:10 local time at Kinnego Cross in Ballymagan, County Donegal. This crash involved two passenger cars, and one driver, a man in his 20s, was pronounced dead at the scene. Three other people involved in the collision – another man in his 20s, a teenage boy and a teenage girl – were transferred to Letterkenny University Hospital for care. Gardaí confirmed none of the three sustained injuries that are expected to be fatal.

    In a public statement following the incidents, Gardaí confirmed that coroners have been formally notified of all three deaths, in line with standard Irish protocol for fatal road incidents. Law enforcement has now launched an investigation into the circumstances of each crash, and is asking members of the public who may have information that could assist inquiries to come forward.

    Specifically, Gardaí is appealing to any road users who were in the area of any of the three collisions at the relevant times, who may have witnessed the events unfold, or who holds dash-camera footage captured from their vehicles around the time and location of each incident to contact local police. Investigators note that even small pieces of witness testimony or short clips of dash-cam footage can provide critical context to help determine the cause of each crash.

  • Heavy rains leave 5 dead in China’s north while Tropical Storm Maysak hits the south and Vietnam

    Heavy rains leave 5 dead in China’s north while Tropical Storm Maysak hits the south and Vietnam

    Extreme weather events have swept across multiple regions of East Asia over the weekend, leaving at least five people dead and triggering widespread flooding and infrastructure damage in northern China and southern coastal areas, Chinese state media confirmed Sunday. The double weather disasters separated by hundreds of kilometers unfolded within a 24-hour window, forcing mass evacuations of at-risk residents and leaving local emergency response teams stretched thin.

    In northern China, two consecutive torrential downpours triggered fatal flash floods and urban inundation. On Saturday evening, a sudden mountain flash flood swept through a rural area in the eastern section of China’s Inner Mongolia Autonomous Region, killing two local villagers, according to official Xinhua News Agency. Local authorities confirmed the pair were moving their cattle herds away from the rising floodwaters when the incident occurred: one drowned while herding livestock, and the other fell into rushing floodwaters while driving the herd to higher ground.

    Just 240 miles southeast of Inner Mongolia, in Fushun City of neighboring Liaoning Province, three more residents died from weather-related incidents on the same day, Xinhua reported, though full details of the fatalities have not yet been released. Fushun was battered by hours of extreme early-morning rainfall Saturday, with one local monitoring site recording a total accumulation of up to 13 inches of rain. Viral footage posted to social media showed major city streets transformed into rushing, waist-deep waterways, displacing thousands of local residents. As of Sunday, approximately 3,600 Fushun residents had been relocated to designated emergency safe shelters.

    While northern China grappled with deadly rain-triggered floods, southern coastal regions faced the impact of Tropical Storm Maysak, which made its second regional landfall over the weekend. After dumping heavy rain across China’s Hainan Island last week, the storm crossed the Gulf of Tonkin and made landfall Saturday night in Vietnam’s Quang Ninh Province, packing maximum sustained winds of 63 miles per hour. As it moved inland, the system gradually weakened from severe tropical storm intensity to standard tropical storm status before tracking northward into China’s Guangxi Zhuang Autonomous Region on Sunday.

    In Fangchenggang, a port city in southern Guangxi, storm-driven rainfall pushed local rivers past their banks, triggering severe flooding that submerged passenger vehicles up to their rooflines, footage from state broadcaster CCTV showed. Local residents told China News Service that the flooding is the worst the region has seen in two decades. Emergency rescue teams deployed inflatable boats to navigate submerged neighborhoods and extract residents trapped in their homes and vehicles. The storm also knocked over mature trees in Dongxing, a Guangxi border city that sits directly adjacent to Vietnam.

    Across the border in Vietnam’s Mong Cai Town, the storm’s strong winds downed trees and tore metal roofing off residential and commercial buildings Saturday evening, Vietnamese state media reported. After wind speeds eased, municipal work crews used chainsaws and heavy construction equipment to clear fallen debris from roadways and reopen blocked transport routes.

    As of Sunday, there has been no update on additional missing persons or the full scale of property damage from either the northern rain events or southern Tropical Storm Maysak.

  • As war grinds on, Ukrainian climbers build a new outdoor culture inspired by Yosemite

    As war grinds on, Ukrainian climbers build a new outdoor culture inspired by Yosemite

    Nestled atop a jagged granite bluff overlooking a winding river, just a two-hour drive west of Ukraine’s capital Kyiv, hundreds of people gathered last week for a unique celebration of outdoor adventure, music, and human connection. This was the 2024 Stoned Climbers festival, Ukraine’s largest outdoor gathering that merges rock climbing with live performances, held in the scenic Zhytomyr region. In a country weathering more than two years of full-scale war, this volunteer-led event balances the joy of ordinary leisure with constant, quiet reminders that conflict remains just over the horizon.

    By day, attendees spread across the landscape: experienced climbers scaled the steep cliff face, casual visitors cooled off in the nearby reservoir, and many tried their hand at stand-up paddleboarding on calm waters. When twilight fell, the forest came alive with sound, as live rock bands and electronic DJs took to the main stage, music drifting through the pine trees to the campground below. Unlike the 2023 iteration of the festival, when attendees watched Russian drones and missiles pass overhead en route to targets in Kyiv, this year’s event passed without enemy aircraft breaching the sky above the campsite. Still, air raid alert notifications pinged on attendees’ phones throughout the weekend, and off-duty soldiers blended quietly into the crowd of climbers and music fans. All profits from this year’s festival are donated to a fundraising campaign supporting Ukraine’s Azov Brigade, tying the event directly to the national war effort.

    The festival traces its roots back to 2023, when a group of 15 climbing-obsessed friends launched the gathering after bonding over their shared love of Yosemite Valley’s iconic climbing culture. The U.S. national park is widely viewed as the birthplace of modern rock climbing, where a distinct counterculture grew around backcountry camping, van life, and multi-month expeditions up the valley’s famous granite walls.

    “We realized climbing could be much more than just a competitive sport,” explained Dmytro Isaienko, 39, one of the festival’s co-founders. “It’s about a specific way of life — rooted in nature, camping, and time spent on the rocks.” The group set out to challenge the widespread belief that rock climbing is an exclusive hobby reserved for elite, professional athletes. Their first gathering in 2023 drew roughly 150 guests; this year, attendance surged to more than 500, the vast majority of whom are beginners or casual amateur climbers.

    Organizing any large public event during wartime brings unique challenges, but Isaienko says the conflict has also given the festival a deeper, more critical purpose. Creating shared, safe spaces where Ukrainians can gather, learn new skills, and connect with one another has become a vital tool to sustain mental and emotional well-being through the strain of prolonged war. “You need to get away from the war for a while,” he said. “Leave Kyiv and come spend some time here together, a little longer than usual.”

    On the rock face below the cliff top, patient instructors work one-on-one with complete beginners, walking them through fastening harnesses, chalking their hands, and spotting the next handhold on the granite. Every time a first-time climber pulls themselves to the top of the 25-meter cliff, spectators, fellow climbers, and instructors erupt in cheers and applause to celebrate the small victory.

    Among this year’s first-time attendees was 21-year-old Liliia Karpach, who traveled from the western Lviv region to attend her first Stoned Climbers festival. “I decided to come because it had been a very long time since I’d climbed on real rocks,” she said. “I also wanted to meet the community in person and get to know new people.” Karpach noted that climbing is as much a mental practice as it is physical exercise, and encouraged others to give it a try: “If you’re really nervous about coming on your own, invite some friends. Even if neither of you knows how to climb, you’ll have a good time together.”

    For 24-year-old instructor Andrii Lamei, helping new climbers build that confidence is the most rewarding part of the festival. While belaying a young first-time climber through the most challenging section of her ascent, he talked her through each movement step by step, helping her steady her nerves. As she climbed higher, her movements grew steadily more sure, and when she finally reached the top, Lamei encouraged her to pause before descending to take in the view. “Look around,” he shouted up to her. “Enjoy the moment. You made it.”

    Lamei says climbing is more than a hobby for Ukrainians navigating the stress of wartime: “Climbing helps you work with stress. It helps you manage stressful situations in everyday life.” Like most Ukrainian men of military age, Lamei is barred from leaving the country under wartime travel restrictions, so he cannot yet fulfill his dream of climbing iconic destinations abroad. “I want to go across the border to visit Yosemite, to visit Norway’s mountains, but I can’t,” he said. “But maybe this is how I’m forced to enjoy what I have here.”

    For Isaienko, that attitude is exactly what makes gatherings like Stoned Climbers so vital for Ukraine right now. While many Ukrainians have put large parts of their lives on hold during the war, he says the growing climbing community taking shape around the Zhytomyr cliffs proves that new traditions can still emerge even amid conflict. “This is a festival for everyone,” he said. “Including people who have never tried climbing before.” And every time another first-time climber reaches the top, the roar of applause rising from the base of the cliff makes clear that little by little, this community of resilience is growing.

  • Businessman and philanthropist Martin Naughton dies

    Businessman and philanthropist Martin Naughton dies

    One of Ireland’s most celebrated entrepreneurs and generous philanthropists, Martin Naughton, has passed away at the age of 87, leaving behind a decades-long legacy of transformative contributions to business development, cross-border cooperation, education and the arts across the whole island of Ireland.

    Naughton began his remarkable business journey in 1973, when he established Glen Electric in the border town of Newry. Just four years later, he pulled off a bold acquisition of a much larger British competitor, rebranding the combined entity as Glen Dimplex in 1977. Under his steady leadership, the company grew exponentially into a global multinational electrical goods giant, today boasting a portfolio of well-known household brands including Morphy Richards and Lec.

    Rather than hoarding the wealth generated by his business success, Naughton channeled much of his fortune into supporting public good initiatives across Ireland. His philanthropic track record is marked by multiple landmark donations that have reshaped cultural and educational institutions. In 2001, Naughton and his wife Carmel gifted £500,000 to endow the Naughton Gallery at Queen’s University Belfast, a space that has remained a hub for artistic expression and public engagement ever since. Six years later, the couple contributed £1 million to the reconstruction project of Belfast’s iconic Lyric Theatre, cementing their support for Northern Ireland’s cultural sector.

    The most significant of the Naughton family’s donations came in 2018, when they gave €25 million (£21.4 million) to Trinity College Dublin – a contribution that still stands as the largest single private philanthropic gift in the history of the Irish state. Academic leaders across Ireland have paid tribute to Naughton’s decades-long commitment to education and institutional growth.

    Professor Sir Ian Greer, President and Vice-Chancellor of Queen’s University Belfast, remembered Naughton as an “exceptional entrepreneur, philanthropist and lifelong champion of education”. He emphasized that Naughton’s vision, generosity and dedication to supporting higher education have created a permanent, lasting impact. “The Naughton Gallery continues to inspire creativity, culture and public engagement, while his longstanding commitment to our university has benefited generations of students and researchers,” Greer noted.

    Dr Linda Doyle, Provost of Trinity College Dublin, echoed these sentiments, saying that Naughton’s legacy at the institution will be felt for hundreds of future students. “It’s been my great honour and privilege to have known such an inspiring and generous man,” Doyle shared in the college’s official statement.

    Beyond business and philanthropy, Naughton – a native of Dundalk, County Louth – was a dedicated advocate for cross-border cooperation on the island of Ireland following decades of division. When InterTradeIreland, the trade promotion body established under the historic Good Friday Agreement, was founded, Naughton served as its very first chairman, helping lay the groundwork for greater economic integration between Northern Ireland and the Republic of Ireland.

  • Paris summer ritual returns with 3 supervised Seine swimming spots

    Paris summer ritual returns with 3 supervised Seine swimming spots

    PARIS — A century after public swimming was banned in the Seine due to unsafe water pollution, a new summer tradition is taking root in the heart of the French capital. For the second consecutive year, Paris city authorities launched three supervised, free public swimming sites along the iconic river on Saturday, opening the once-forbidden waterway to locals and tourists alike.

    The three swimming zones are strategically located across the city: one near the Paris City Hall, a second at the Grenelle site within sight of the Eiffel Tower, and a third in eastern Paris. They are scheduled to remain open throughout the warm summer months, with operations contingent on daily water quality assessments and prevailing weather conditions. To ensure visitor safety, all sites operate under constant supervision from certified lifeguards, and official testing of water purity is conducted every single morning before opening to the public.

    This milestone comes after the Seine hosted open-water swimming and triathlon events during the 2024 Paris Olympic Games. The high-profile international competition accelerated a massive, multibillion-euro river cleanup initiative launched by city authorities. The project included sweeping upgrades to Paris’s aging sewer network, construction of large-scale new rainwater storage facilities, and a series of other targeted interventions designed to cut polluted runoff into the river — work that finally reversed a century of declining water quality.

    Public swimming in the Seine was outlawed nearly 100 years ago because of rampant pollution from untreated urban waste. For decades, Parisians seeking open-water summer swimming have only had access to designated public sites along a canal in the city’s northeast. Even after the 2024 rule change, last summer’s launch faced setbacks: multiple swimming days had to be canceled after heavy rainfalls increased pollution levels in upstream sections of the river, triggering health safety protocols.

    This year, site managers have put new crowd control measures in place to handle the expected influx of visitors seeking relief from summer heat waves. At the popular Grenelle site near the Eiffel Tower, deputy site manager Clémence Donazzan explained that the zone has a maximum capacity of 200 swimmers at any given time. A queuing system operates at the entrance, with staff monitoring visitor numbers in real time to prevent overcrowding. “Everyone will eventually have access, even if there’s a short wait,” Donazzan noted.

    For the many visitors already trying out the new sites, the experience has exceeded expectations. Stewart Talbot, a tourist from Melbourne, Australia who is spending a week in Paris, called the opportunity to swim in the Seine against the backdrop of the Eiffel Tower unforgettable. “It’s amazing to be swimming in the Seine while looking at the Eiffel Tower,” Talbot said. “Maybe it’s not as good as the sea in Australia, but it’s better than our rivers.”

    The initiative has also proven popular with Parisians of all ages, who have embraced the new public amenity. Nineteen-year-old Hermine Jegou, a local resident, praised the inclusive, cross-generational atmosphere of the swimming sites. “It’s great because it’s such a mix of people,” she said. “I love that everyone can get into the water — grandmothers, children — it’s just really nice.” Her 21-year-old sister Joanne Jegou agreed, saying she already planned to return. “It’s such a cool experience, especially being out in the sun and cooling off,” she said.

  • ‘America’s 250th birthday is our 50th  anniversary’

    ‘America’s 250th birthday is our 50th anniversary’

    Half a century ago, on a momentous national holiday that doubled as their most important personal celebration, Roger Lieb and Bonnie Taff said their wedding vows. Their choice of wedding date – July 4, 1976 – was no random selection: that year marked the United States’ 200th anniversary of independence, turning a small private ceremony into an event intertwined with a nationwide celebration. Now, as the nation prepares to mark its 250th birthday in 2026, the pair is gearing up to celebrate their own golden wedding anniversary, a rare coincidence that ties their lifelong relationship directly to America’s modern historical milestones. In an exclusive interview with the BBC, the couple opened up about the unique joys and unexpected quirks of sharing their biggest life moment with one of the country’s largest national parties. They shared stories of packed public venues, spontaneous celebrations from strangers who joined in to toast the newlyweds amid bicentennial parades, and how the overlapping milestone has shaped the way they reflect on their decades together. For 50 years, their anniversary has always come with double the festivities: every Fourth of July, as communities across the nation light fireworks and host barbecues to mark independence, the Lieb and Taff family adds their own anniversary cakes, toasts, and reunions to the celebration. The couple recalled that even on their original wedding day, the overlapping national celebration created a joyful, chaotic atmosphere that they have never forgotten. Many of their guests were already planning holiday gatherings, so the wedding fit seamlessly into long-awaited plans, and strangers on the street stopped to congratulate them after noticing their wedding attire amid the bicentennial crowds. Looking back, both agree that tying their love story to the nation’s history has given their relationship an extra layer of meaning, turning every anniversary into a reminder of both their shared journey and the passage of time across the country they call home.

  • Autism remains widely misunderstood in parts of Africa. A mother in Guinea fights for her child

    Autism remains widely misunderstood in parts of Africa. A mother in Guinea fights for her child

    In the small Guinean town of Fria, 15-year-old Kazaliou Balde’s journey through life has been shaped by deep-rooted misconceptions about autism and a systemic lack of support for neurodivergent people in one of West Africa’s poorest nations. From his earliest childhood, Balde’s unusual social behaviors—avoiding eye contact, struggling to connect with others, and later, an inability to walk unassisted—left his family confused and desperate for answers.

    Like many Guinean families facing unfamiliar developmental conditions, Balde’s parents first turned to traditional healing, seeking protective amulets to ward off what many community members already whispered was a curse from evil spirits. When his condition did not improve, the family traveled to the capital Conakry for a formal diagnosis, where doctors confirmed what none of them had ever heard of: autism spectrum disorder.

    The stigma that followed the diagnosis was immediate and cruel. Neighbors whispered about the boy, made demeaning comments to his family, and even urged his mother, 55-year-old trader Kadiatou Diallo, to abandon Balde in the remote bush. “Some suggested that I take him to the bush and throw him away,” Diallo recalled.

    Deep-seated misinformation about autism is not an isolated issue in Guinea. Across much of sub-Saharan Africa, a crippling lack of reliable population data, public awareness campaigns, and government support has allowed harmful myths about neurodevelopmental conditions to persist. Experts confirm these misconceptions routinely delay life-changing diagnosis and force generations of autistic children and their families to carry unnecessary social stigma. Many families still hide their autistic loved ones away at home to avoid public mockery and rejection.

    Autism spectrum disorder is a complex neurodevelopmental condition that impacts people in wildly varying ways. It can cause delays in language development, learning, and social-emotional processing, ranging from profound nonverbal autism accompanied by intellectual disability to milder symptoms that allow for independent living. The World Health Organization estimated that one in every 127 people globally lived with autism in 2021, but prevalence data for most low- and middle-income countries, including Guinea, remains uncollected and unknown. The Guinean government currently keeps no official records of autism diagnoses or cases nationwide.

    For Diallo, the diagnosis did not lead to despair—it sparked a fierce determination to secure care and dignity for her son. After her late husband spent years traveling across Guinea searching for support before dying in a road accident, hope finally arrived in their own hometown. In 2023, the newly opened Salim Foundation for Children with Autism, a rare tuition-free facility for autistic youth, conducted a community outreach sweep, identified Balde’s unmet needs, and enrolled him in their program.

    Founded by social worker and philanthropist Mariam Aisha Barry—who launched the initiative inspired by her own autistic daughter—the Salim Foundation currently serves 15 students in a repurposed residential home, with three specialized teachers, bright educational toys, and sensory-friendly learning spaces. Unlike traditional schools that failed to accommodate Balde’s needs, the foundation focuses on building foundational daily living skills: identifying common objects, assembling educational toys, and mastering practical tasks like using a television remote. Registered with Guinean educational authorities but entirely self-funded, the foundation made history last year by organizing Guinea’s first ever international autism awareness seminar.

    “Our mission is to break the stigma surrounding autism through awareness-raising, family training and advocacy for better care,” Barry explained. “These children deserve acceptance, understanding, education and unconditional love.”

    Even with Balde now enrolled in the program, stigma still follows him outside the school’s walls. Many community members continue to view his condition as a mark of evil and demand he be shunned from public life, but Diallo has refused to bow to this pressure. She rejected repeated calls to pull him out of school and hide him away, standing firm against the negative judgments that have followed her son for his entire life.

    Across Guinea, a country of 15 million people, only a tiny number of schools cater to autistic children, and most charge monthly fees of up to $300—an unimaginable sum for most Guinean households. The national minimum wage sits at just $63 per month, and the World Bank estimates 43.7% of Guineans live below the international poverty line. “In Guinea, the care for autism is very poor,” noted Dr. Alhassane Cherif, a Conakry-based clinical psychologist. “Private organizations and nonprofits are the only ones addressing this disorder and training staff to try to identify children.”

    Advocates at the Salim Foundation estimate that hundreds of autistic children remain hidden in family homes across Fria alone, kept out of sight by parents terrified of social stigma. “We have 15 autistic children here, but there are several hundred in this city,” said Hassanatou Diallo, the foundation’s advocacy officer. “Some parents hide them in their homes to avoid mockery and stigmatization.”

    Global research gaps compound these local challenges. A 2023 study published in the Review Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders labeled sub-Saharan Africa a “critically understudied” region for autism research, noting that the region’s extraordinary genetic diversity could unlock critical global insights into autism’s origins and interventions. Without targeted investment in research and support, however, millions of autistic children across the continent will continue to be left behind.

    For Diallo, the fight is personal. Despite every obstacle placed in her path, she remains committed to securing an education for Balde, holding fast to a simple, heartfelt dream: “My most ardent wish is that he knows how to read and write,” she said.

  • Row after Indian state drops eggs from school lunch menu

    Row after Indian state drops eggs from school lunch menu

    A proposed policy shift in India’s eastern state of West Bengal, which would remove eggs from some government school mid-day meals in favor of vegetarian alternatives, has ignited fierce public and expert debate across the country, touching on questions of nutrition accessibility, ideological influence, and the future of the world’s largest school feeding program.

    The controversy began last week, when West Bengal’s newly elected Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) government announced it would hand over preparation of mid-day meals for Kolkata Municipal Corporation-run schools to the Annamitra Foundation, a food service arm of the International Society for Krishna Consciousness (Iskcon) — the Hindu organization more widely known as the Hare Krishna movement. Iskcon follows strict vegetarian dietary practices, so the plan will swap eggs for plant-based protein sources. As of yet, no final decisions have been made, the organization confirmed to the BBC, and it remains unclear whether the pilot will ever launch or expand to other schools across the state. That has not stopped the proposal from reigniting a long-running national argument over what belongs on the plates of millions of vulnerable schoolchildren.

    India’s federal mid-day meal scheme, first launched nationwide in 1995 after decades of local testing, has grown into the largest school feeding initiative on Earth, serving free cooked lunches to more than 110 million students across government and government-aided schools. For millions of children from low-income households, the daily meal is the most nutritious — and sometimes the only — full meal they consume in a day. For decades, the program has been widely praised for cutting childhood hunger, improving nutrition outcomes, and boosting school enrollment and retention among marginalized communities. While the Indian central government sets minimum calorie and protein requirements for meals, individual states are given full authority to design their own menus, leading to wide variation across the country: states including Tamil Nadu and Bihar regularly serve eggs alongside grain and vegetable dishes, while others like Gujarat and Uttar Pradesh exclusively offer vegetarian options.

    Nutrition campaigners and public health experts have widely pushed back against the West Bengal proposal, arguing that eggs are one of the most accessible, affordable, and nutritionally complete sources of protein for growing children from low-income backgrounds. At roughly 8 Indian rupees (around $0.08) per egg, the food has been a staple of Bengali culinary culture for generations, and its nutritional profile is hard to match on a public budget. Fareha Shanam, a nutritionist at Delhi’s Sir Ganga Ram Hospital, explained that eggs contain all nine essential amino acids that the human body cannot produce on its own, alongside critical micronutrients including vitamin D and vitamin B12. While plant-based options like pulses and legumes do offer protein, Shanam noted that they have higher fiber content and a less balanced amino acid profile. Alternatives like paneer (Indian cottage cheese) can match eggs’ nutrition, she added, but cost far more, making regular service unfeasible for a publicly funded program that operates on tight budgets.

    Dr. Vamshi V, a consultant internal medicine physician at Hyderabad’s Gleneagles Aware Hospital, warned that removing eggs without carefully crafting nutritionally equivalent substitutes could have long-term negative impacts on children’s health. “For many children, the school meal is the most nutrient-dense food they get all day,” she explained. A shortfall of essential protein and micronutrients may not cause immediate visible harm, she added, but over time it can hinder physical growth, impair cognitive development and learning, and weaken children’s immune systems.

    Critics of the policy have also accused the BJP government of allowing religious ideology to shape public nutrition policy. The opposition All India Trinamool Congress (TMC), which held power in West Bengal until May 2026, has claimed the government is seeking to “impose vegetarianism” on schoolchildren. Iskcon and state leaders have rejected these accusations. West Bengal Chief Minister Suvendu Adhikari defended the plan, framing it as an effort to provide students with “good and pure food” and emphasizing that no one would be forced to participate in the organization’s religious practices. Iskcon officials note that the group already serves 1 million school meals daily across 16 Indian states through its Akshaya Patra Foundation, and that its vegetarian menus are designed to meet all national nutritional requirements. Radharaman Das, until last week Iskcon’s Kolkata vice-president, told local media that the organization prioritizes nutrition and hygiene in its meal preparation, and that the proposed vegetarian menu would match the protein and vitamin content of egg-inclusive meals. Notably, Das has since been removed from his leadership posts, though Iskcon has not publicly shared a reason for the personnel change, and has not responded to the BBC’s request for comment on the decision.

    Other critics have pointed out that the plant-based substitutes proposed by Iskcon, including soybeans and kidney beans, are not widely consumed in West Bengal and may be rejected by students, leaving many without the protein they need. Several politicians and activists have proposed a compromise solution that has already been tested in some regions: offering students a choice between an egg and a vegetarian alternative. In a Bihar school, for example, students receive an egg every Friday, while those who prefer a vegetarian option get a banana instead, with no coercion either way.

    Reactions to the proposed change among parents and students in Kolkata have been mixed. Some young students told the BBC they welcomed the shift as a break from their regular routine, while others expressed disappointment, noting they looked forward to the days of the week when eggs are served. Chaitali Mitra, a 37-year-old parent whose daughter attends a local government school, said she believed eggs were a critical part of the school meal. “It would reassure me that my growing child’s protein needs were being fulfilled,” she said.

    For teachers across the country who work with low-income students, the debate underscores the non-negotiable importance of the mid-day meal program itself. “The mid-day meals have been among the biggest reasons for students getting admissions in primary schools,” an unnamed Delhi primary school teacher said. Many children arrive at school hungry every day, she added, and wait eagerly for their daily lunch.

  • More cows than pupils – what is behind mass school closures in rural Kenya?

    More cows than pupils – what is behind mass school closures in rural Kenya?

    On a morning that would normally hum with the chatter of playing children and the scratch of pencils on paper, Kaliluni Primary School, a remote rural learning institution in southern Kenya, hosts only grazing cows. These animals wander between cracked, half-hanging classroom doors, which gape open to reveal neat rows of unoccupied wooden chairs. Three years ago, more than 200 students filled this small campus with noise and energy. Today, just five children remain enrolled – and on the day a BBC reporting team visited, even those five and their school’s only remaining teacher were nowhere to be found.

    Leaving the crumbling, overgrown school compound, where tattered textbooks lie scattered across dusty classroom floors, reporters spotted 12-year-old Maureen Mwisiwa in her starched blue school uniform, walking slowly and dejectedly toward her home. Maureen told the BBC she had shown up to Kaliluni every day for a week, only to find herself completely alone with no classes to attend. “I feel bad missing lessons all those days while pupils in other schools are still in class,” she explained.

    Her mother, Josephine Muasya, is one of the last remaining parents with a child enrolled at the school, and she is preparing to transfer Maureen to a distant campus where most of the girl’s former classmates have already relocated. The new school sits 8 kilometers (5 miles) away across unmaintained, rocky roads. With no public transit service in this isolated region of Kitui County, more than 200 kilometers east of Kenya’s capital Nairobi, children cut across steep, uneven terrain to shorten their commute. Even with the shortcut, Maureen will walk for more than an hour each way, compared to the 10-minute trip she took to reach Kaliluni.

    Muasya says she once held out hope that the national government would intervene to revive her local school, sending additional trained teachers and upgraded facilities to meet the requirements of Kenya’s new national curriculum. Today, that hope is gone. The curriculum Muasya refers to is the Competency-Based Education (CBE) system, a sweeping national education overhaul rolled out in 2017 designed to replace Kenya’s old exam-heavy model with a more creative, practical, skills-focused approach to learning.

    While the reform was intended to reduce educational inequality across the country, it has triggered an unforeseen crisis for Kenya’s most under-resourced rural primary schools. Kaliluni Primary is just one of more than 2,000 rural schools across the East African nation now facing permanent closure after catastrophic enrollment collapses.

    Under the previous education framework, primary school spanned eight grades, with students moving to senior secondary school around age 14. The CBE system restructures basic education to end primary school after grade six, adding a new three-year junior secondary stage for grades seven through nine, which places greater emphasis on science and hands-on technical subjects. The government ruled that existing primary schools would absorb these new junior secondary grades, pushing the transition to senior school to age 15.

    But the restructuring created an immediate, unmanageable burden for low-resource rural schools, which suddenly needed additional classrooms, fully equipped science laboratories, subject-specialized trained teachers, and updated learning materials to comply with the new requirements.

    “Infrastructure gaps are acute. Many rural schools lack basic facilities such as laboratories, yet learners are expected to pursue science and technical pathways,” Mark Kasyoki, a Kenyan education expert, told the BBC. He warned that the CBE curriculum, which was designed to close equality gaps in Kenyan education by making quality learning free for all students, could end up widening those gaps if implementation challenges are not addressed as a matter of urgency.

    Kitui County has been one of the hardest-hit regions. Sooma Primary School permanently closed its doors in 2023 after enrollment dropped to just six students. The following year, Manooni Primary shut down after only three children registered for the new term. There were no closing ceremonies, no goodbye gatherings under the giant shade trees that anchor most rural schoolyards. Students simply left one by one, quietly relocating to better-resourced schools farther from their homes.

    Tabitha Katingu, a Kitui County mother who transferred both of her children to a new school 3 kilometers from her home after their local campus shut down, says the CBE reform was supposed to lift up low-income rural communities, not undermine their access to education. “The CBE curriculum should strengthen schools, especially for low-income communities, not weaken them. We want the best for our children. If a school has not enough trained teachers and other required facilities – why would we waste time there?” she said.

    The transition crisis has also left rural teachers frustrated and disillusioned. “The challenge is not that teachers are unwilling to embrace CBE. It’s that many of us have not been adequately prepared for it. The training has been inconsistent, especially in rural schools,” one Kitui-based teacher explained.

    Not all local residents blame the school closure crisis entirely on the curriculum overhaul. Some point to broader demographic shifts reshaping rural Kenya: falling national fertility rates have led to fewer school-age children in small villages, while working-age adults increasingly relocate to urban centers for better employment opportunities, taking their children with them.

    “Young people want to marry, but life is hard. Everything is expensive, and many fear they cannot provide for a family. That is why there are fewer children growing up in our villages nowadays,” Sarah Mumbua, a long-time resident of Kilukuya village, told the BBC. National statistics show roughly 70% of Kenyans still lived in rural areas in 2023, but UN-Habitat projects that more than half of the country’s population will live in urban areas by 2050 as migration continues.

    The enrollment decline is not limited to primary schools: government data shows 2,700 of Kenya’s 9,605 public secondary schools, most in remote rural regions, now enroll fewer than the 150 students deemed the minimum for viable operations. Local media reported earlier this year that 10 rural secondary schools were closed after teachers arrived for the new term to find zero students had registered for classes.

    In January 2026, the government celebrated a major milestone for the CBE reform: 1.1 million pioneer grade 10 students, the first full cohort to complete the entire new curriculum, transitioned to senior secondary school. But even as officials marked the occasion, they acknowledged the growing crisis in rural areas.

    Education Minister Julius Ogamba confirmed earlier this year that 2,145 under-enrolled public primary schools will be either closed or merged with neighboring campuses to optimize limited government resources. He also announced a nationwide school viability audit, noting that the government has set a minimum enrollment threshold of 45 students for a public primary school to remain open. “It makes no sense to have a school with just 10 students when you need a headmaster, a classroom, a watchman and a teacher. It doesn’t make sense. This tells us that we need to face reality. We now need to change course and ensure that our schools have all the necessary facilities and the right number of students,” he said.

    But the wave of rural school closures has created a new crisis for surviving regional schools, which are now facing crippling overcrowding as they struggle to absorb hundreds of displaced students. Dr. Emmanuel Manyasa, CEO of Usawa Agenda, a Kenyan non-profit education research organization, warns that rapid mass closures carry long-term risks for the entire regional education system.

    “CBE is a good curriculum but we’re failing in the implementation. We skipped critical early stages like a cost and implementation plan. We have been just crisis-managing the transition, which is not sustainable,” Dr. Manyasa told the BBC.

    Bernard Musyoki, a 36-year-old teacher who worked for seven years in a rural Machakos County school (a region neighboring Kitui), saw the impact of closures firsthand. His small community school, which had fewer than 20 students enrolled, was merged into a larger regional campus, and Musyoki transferred to the new overcrowded facility. He says policymakers have swung from one extreme to another, leaving children in larger schools stuck in overcrowded classrooms that lack sufficient resources.

    Musyoki argues the government should reverse course on mass closures, instead capping class sizes and distributing teachers and resources more evenly across rural institutions to ensure the CBE reform benefits all students, regardless of where they live. “Every child, whether they are in a small rural school or a large one, deserves equal access to teachers, classrooms and learning materials,” he said.