The National Rugby League is facing growing backlash over a controversial off-season rule overhaul, with one of the code’s most respected veteran coaches becoming the latest high-profile voice to condemn the change, arguing it has eroded the sport’s core identity.
Ricky Stuart, head coach of the Canberra Raiders, once supported the NRL’s updated ‘six again’ rule interpretation, which was introduced during the 2024 off-season. Under the new regulation, referees award attacking teams an immediate set restart instead of a traditional penalty for ruck infringements or offside offences committed outside the 20-metre line. The rule was framed as a way to cut down on match stoppages and speed up overall gameplay, but it has sparked fierce pushback from fans and insiders alike.
Stuart, who has led Canberra for more than a decade, said his initial optimism about the change has faded, as the rule has had unintended negative consequences that have hurt the quality of on-field product. Speaking ahead of the Raiders’ blockbuster Friday night home match against a Melbourne Storm side that has dropped four consecutive matches, Stuart said the league has lost the fundamental fabric of the sport that long-time fans love.
“I was a fan of the six again, but I think we’ve lost the fabric of the game,” Stuart told reporters, aligning himself with thousands of fans who have voiced criticism of the rule on social media. “Six agains are just given now willy-nilly. There’s a free six again wave of the arm because there’s no repercussion on the decision right at the time. For me, a six again is something that has got to be penalty worthy, but I don’t think it is at the moment which is why we’re getting so much criticism with the speed of the game. Making the game faster doesn’t necessarily make it more attractive. Just because the scoreline is 50-30, I don’t believe it’s more attractive.”
Proponents of the rule argue it has created more attacking opportunities and higher overall scores, which they claim makes matches more exciting for viewers. But critics, including Stuart, point out that the change has led to massively lopsided scorelines and forced defending teams to endure dozens of consecutive tackles, leading to excessive player fatigue late in matches that threatens both competitive balance and athlete welfare. While some top teams have adapted quickly and thrived under the new regulations, others have struggled to adjust to the relentless pace of play.
Beyond the rule debate, Stuart confirmed a series of reshuffles to his Raiders starting side for this week’s clash, highlighted by a young winger’s personal request to step back to reserve grade. Twenty-one-year-old Savelio Tamale, who is in just his second full season of first-grade NRL, asked to drop down a level to rebuild his confidence after an unusual moment in last week’s match against South Sydney Rabbitohs in Perth. Video footage showed Tamale appearing to slow to a stop just centimetres from the try line before eventually grounding the ball for a five-pointer, a moment that sparked widespread discussion online.
Stuart moved to shut down speculation around the incident, saying it is simply a matter of a young player working through a confidence slump, a challenge Tamale previously navigated last year following an injury spell. “He’s just down on confidence,” Stuart explained. “We don’t need to make it too big a story internally, because for us, we’ve just got to look after a young player who is lacking a bit of confidence. The same thing happened to him last year when he came back from injury. He’ll get through it. Outside of him being a talented footballer, he’s a really good bloke so he’ll get through it because he’s got good people around him and we’ll take care of him.”
Tamale’s move to reserve grade has opened up a spot in the starting line-up, forcing a positional reshuffle: Seb Kris will shift from centre to left wing, allowing Matt Timoko to return to the starting side at centre for the first time in 2024. Timoko lost his starting spot to Simi Sasagi earlier in the season after an injury-interrupted off-season kept him out of match practice, and his stint in reserve grade sparked widespread speculation that he could seek a move away from Canberra before his current contract expires.
Stuart was quick to dismiss those rumours, saying Timoko has acted with the utmost professionalism throughout his spell out of the starting side and remains a key part of the Raiders’ long-term plans. The coach added that Timoko, one of the NRL’s most talented attacking centres, only needed more time in reserve grade to work on his defensive fundamentals, and that he has no intention of leaving the club.
“Matty has been amazing how he’s sat back and just kept working hard because he knows how well Simi has been playing,” Stuart said. “Even Matty said to me two weeks ago when I sat down and had a chat with him, ‘Mate, it’s hard at the moment because we’ve got Simi playing so well’, and he was fine with it and totally got it. He went back and kept working hard on his football and now he’s back in the team. He’s a club person so I know he’s excited and he’s ready to play. He’s here next year. That happens at any club when a first-grader comes back from injury and isn’t playing first grade or is put back to Cup to fix his game. All of a sudden there’s innuendo about the player being disgruntled or wants out. Matty’s not disgruntled and he doesn’t want out, and he hasn’t come and seen me. I’ve had good conversations with his manager so everything is OK from our point of view.”
Friday’s match between the 2-win Raiders and 2-win Storm shapes as a critical turning point for both sides, who are desperate to reverse their poor early-season form and climb up the NRL ladder.