US healthcare needs fixing, but there’s no agreement on how to do it

The American healthcare system continues to generate devastating financial consequences for millions of citizens, exemplified by the case of Jeff King, a 66-year-old former pastor from Lawrence, Kansas. Following a routine procedure to correct his irregular heart rhythm, King received an astonishing $160,000 medical bill that threatened to bankrupt him. Despite having a cost-sharing alternative plan, his coverage excluded the treatment entirely.

King’s predicament reflects a national crisis where approximately 100 million Americans—roughly 40% of the population—struggle with medical and dental debt. The United States maintains the world’s most expensive healthcare system, with projected expenditures reaching $5.9 trillion in 2026 according to Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services data. Paradoxically, despite per capita healthcare spending that doubles that of comparable wealthy nations, America demonstrates lower life expectancy rates according to research from nonprofit KFF.

The system’s failures have generated widespread public frustration, sometimes with tragic consequences. In December 2024, UnitedHealthCare CEO Brian Thompson was fatally shot in Manhattan by Luigi Mangione, who subsequently gained support from protesters viewing him as a folk hero opposing the healthcare establishment. While a judge recently dismissed federal firearms murder charges against Mangione, the incident highlights the intense emotions surrounding healthcare affordability.

Political solutions remain elusive despite bipartisan recognition of systemic problems. Former President Donald Trump recently proposed his “Great Healthcare Plan” featuring direct payments to citizens for insurance costs and eliminating “kickbacks” to middlemen. However, experts note the plan lacks critical details regarding funding mechanisms and implementation strategies.

The Affordable Care Act (ACA) implemented under President Obama significantly expanded coverage but created a patchwork system that falls short of universal healthcare. A decade after full implementation, frustrations persist as approximately 20% of privately insured Americans reported claim denials for doctor-recommended care in 2023.

The expiration of COVID-era subsidies has exacerbated the crisis, with millions facing dramatic premium increases. Stacy Cox, a Utah-based photographer with high breast cancer risk, saw her insurance costs quadruple from $500 to $2,100 monthly, forcing her to abandon comprehensive coverage. Similarly, Mike Short, a Tennessee graphic artist with preexisting medical debt, now risks financial ruin from potential health complications.

Structural complexities involving multiple overlapping systems—Medicare, Medicaid, employer-sponsored insurance, and veteran’s healthcare—create bureaucratic inefficiencies and confusion. Health policy experts advocate for system consolidation and stronger price negotiation mechanisms for pharmaceuticals.

While some states have implemented local solutions such as banning medical debt from credit reports and providing separate subsidies, the federal government struggles to achieve consensus. As healthcare companies have tripled profits over two decades and distributed $2.6 trillion to shareholders since 2001, ordinary Americans continue facing impossible choices between financial stability and essential medical care.