Real Madrid faces a defining moment in their season as manager Xabi Alonso’s tenure reaches a critical juncture following a disastrous 2-0 La Liga defeat to Celta Vigo. The loss—met with thunderous boos from the Bernabéu faithful—prompted emergency meetings among the club’s hierarchy, casting serious doubt on Alonso’s future just months into his ambitious project.
The Spanish giants have won only one of their last five league matches, leaving them four points behind rivals Barcelona despite a strong start that included a victory over Barça in October. Alonso, who arrived promising a modern, high-intensity style he dubbed “rock and roll” football, now confronts a squad struggling to execute his tactical vision.
Internal tensions have reached boiling point. The dressing room erupted in frustration after Sunday’s match, with reports of thrown objects and heated exchanges. While Alonso criticized officiating, players immediately dismissed such excuses, acknowledging deeper systemic issues.
The core problem appears to be a fundamental disconnect between Alonso’s meticulous methodology and the players’ execution. Despite preparing specific strategies like high pressing and rapid tempo control, the team has consistently failed to implement these plans during matches—a concern previously warned by former manager Carlo Ancelotti.
Complicating matters are individual agendas within the squad. Kylian Mbappé’s pursuit of personal records, Vinícius Júnior’s concerns about team authority, and Federico Valverde’s positional preferences have created conflicting interests. Jude Bellingham’s adaptation to a midfield role has also proven challenging, limiting his effectiveness.
Defensive injuries have forced Alonso to use 20 different lineups in 21 matches, with Eder Militão now joining the casualty list for 3-4 months. The attack has similarly struggled—when Mbappé doesn’t score, others rarely contribute, with Vinícius enduring an 11-game drought and Rodrygo going 33 matches without a goal.
President Florentino Pérez, who never fully embraced this philosophical shift, now faces a familiar dilemma. His historical preference for less interventionist coaches like Ancelotti or Zinedine Zidane suggests Alonso’s detailed approach may prove his undoing.
Wednesday’s Champions League clash against Manchester City now represents more than just a tournament fixture—it could determine Alonso’s fate. Should Madrid part ways with their manager, potential successors include Zidane and current B-team coach Álvaro Arbeloa.