UK, France and China vote against UAE’s Lana Nusseibeh at UN

The ongoing contest to select the next United Nations Secretary-General to succeed incumbent Antonio Guterres hit a major impasse on Friday, as prominent Emirati diplomat Lana Nusseibeh faced a critical barrier in the latest informal Security Council straw poll. Three of the five permanent veto-wielding members of the UN Security Council (P5) — the United Kingdom, France, and China — cast “discourage” votes against Nusseibeh, derailing her path to the top global diplomatic post, according to diplomatic and insiders close to the closed-door process who spoke to Middle East Eye. While straw poll ballots are anonymous, sources confirmed the remaining two P5 members, the United States and Russia, alongside non-Security Council member Israel, have publicly expressed backing for the Emirati candidate, who currently serves as UAE Minister of State and previously held the post of UAE Permanent Representative to the UN. The latest round of voting yielded identical results to the 6 November straw poll for Nusseibeh: seven “encourage” votes, six “discourage” votes, and two “no opinion” votes. To advance a candidate to the UN General Assembly for formal appointment, a nominee must secure a minimum of nine total votes from the 15-member Security Council, with zero negative votes from any P5 member, a threshold Nusseibeh has yet to clear. The current perceived frontrunner, Costa Rican economist and diplomat Rebeca Grynspan, earned 10 “encourage” votes but carries two “discourage” votes from P5 members widely identified as Russia and the US, while Argentina’s Rafael Grossi — a candidate backed by Argentina’s far-right president Javier Milei and also favored by Washington — received three negative votes from P5 representatives. The cross-P5 lack of consensus has left the entire selection process fully deadlocked. Undeterred by the setback, Nusseibeh reaffirmed her commitment to the campaign in a public post on X, stating, “I remain fully committed to this campaign and will continue engaging Member States to earn their support and make the case for a more active, results-focused and responsive United Nations.” The Abu Dhabi-born diplomat’s bid has drawn sustained criticism from civil society groups over the UAE’s alleged involvement in the ongoing Sudan conflict. Nusseibeh has repeatedly rejected findings from a UN Panel of Experts that the UAE provides material support to the Rapid Support Forces (RSF), the Darfur-based paramilitary group that both the UN and US have formally designated as responsible for ongoing genocide in the region. Recent reporting from Middle East Eye revealed that Nusseibeh held a private lobbying meeting with Iain Duncan Smith, former leader of the UK’s Conservative Party, shortly after Duncan Smith delivered a speech in the UK Parliament accusing the UAE of sponsoring widespread terrorism in Sudan, and urging the British government to deploy its UN Security Council veto to block Nusseibeh’s candidacy. During that meeting, Duncan Smith reiterated his parliamentary criticism of UAE actions in Sudan — allegations Abu Dhabi firmly denies — and demanded the immediate release of two British nationals, Ryan Cornelius and Charles Ridley, who have been detained in Dubai for nearly 20 years. He told Nusseibeh that her UN candidacy presented the UAE with a clear opportunity to take positive action by ending its involvement in the Sudan war and freeing the two detained men, adding that the Emirati state was engaging in systemic corruption that warranted a firm response from UK Foreign Secretary Ed Miliband. The coordinated “discourage” votes from the UK, France and China appear to reflect the UK government acting on that call for a firm stance. Despite the significant setback, both Nusseibeh and the UAE government remain fully invested in pushing her candidacy forward, with a former British government official noting to MEE that Abu Dhabi retains significant leverage via its extensive global network of financial investment and development partnerships. A spokesperson for Nusseibeh’s campaign, responding to a request for comment from Middle East Eye on Friday, stated: “Lana Nusseibeh is meeting a wide range of stakeholders as part of her candidacy for UN secretary-general. We do not comment on the content of private meetings. Lana has taken a leave of absence from her ministerial role since the submission of her nomination. She took this decision as part of her genuine commitment to the independence of her campaign and potential future role.”