Jimmy Lai severely sentenced despite Trump calling for his release

Hong Kong’s High Court has delivered a landmark 20-year prison sentence to media entrepreneur and pro-democracy activist Jimmy Lai Chee-ying, marking one of the most significant applications of the territory’s National Security Law since its implementation in 2020. The 78-year-old founder of the defunct Apple Daily was convicted on charges of conspiring with foreign forces and publishing seditious materials, primarily stemming from his 2019 appeals to Washington for support of Hong Kong protesters and pressure on Beijing during trade negotiations.

The sentencing decision, handed down by three judges on Monday, concludes a lengthy legal process that began with Lai’s initial detention in December 2020. In addition to Lai’s substantial term, six former Apple Daily executives and two activists received prison sentences ranging from six years and three months to ten years for related national security violations.

The case has drawn significant international attention, with former U.S. President Donald Trump reportedly raising Lai’s situation directly with Chinese President Xi Jinping during an October meeting in South Korea. Trump suggested that Lai’s release could potentially stabilize Sino-American relations and improve China’s global standing. The former president has previously vowed to secure Lai’s freedom if re-elected.

Chinese authorities have maintained a firm stance regarding the judicial proceedings. Foreign Ministry spokesperson Lin Jian emphasized that Lai’s case represents an internal matter for Hong Kong, describing the activist as “the principal mastermind and perpetrator behind the series of riots that shook Hong Kong.” Lin further urged foreign nations to respect China’s sovereignty and refrain from interfering in Hong Kong’s judicial independence.

The prosecution built its case around Lai’s alleged coordination with foreign officials, including meetings with former U.S. Secretary of State Mike Pompeo, and his newspaper’s coverage of the 2019 protests. Controversially, pro-Beijing media outlets reported that Lai had encouraged the United States to deploy “nuclear weapons” against China, though contextual evidence indicates the businessman was employing metaphorical language regarding America’s “moral authority” in international relations.

Complicating the diplomatic dimension, British officials have explored potential transfer arrangements under the still-active Transfer of Sentenced Persons Agreement between the UK and Hong Kong. However, Hong Kong’s Security Bureau has clarified that such mechanisms do not apply to Chinese nationals, noting that China does not recognize dual citizenship despite Lai’s British naturalization in 1994.

The sentencing occurs against a backdrop of ongoing geopolitical tensions, with Trump scheduled to meet Xi in Beijing this April and critical midterm elections approaching in the United States. The outcome of these diplomatic engagements may influence the future of Sino-American relations, including the expiration of a current trade truce between the nations in November.