‘Better Call Ivan’: Ivan Cleary’s advice to the judiciary as Panthers coach shuts down revenge theory

Penrith Panthers coach Ivan Cleary has emphatically declared his retirement from legal advocacy duties following a successful judiciary appearance that overturned his son Nathan’s suspension. The four-time premiership-winning mentor temporarily swapped his coaching attire for formal wear last week, delivering a compelling defense that reduced a potential three-match ban to a mere fine.

The contentious case centered on a tackle during a trial match that the match review committee had initially graded as warranting suspension. Cleary presented visual evidence demonstrating the absence of direct head contact, securing his halfback’s availability for the season opener against Brisbane.

Expressing frustration with the judicial process, Cleary criticized the system’s inherent flaws, particularly the risk-reward calculation that forces clubs to weigh challenging incorrect decisions against potential extended bans. ‘It was quite a big thing – either no weeks or three weeks for something that was pretty clearly a grade one,’ Cleary remarked, highlighting the disproportionate consequences clubs face.

The veteran coach specifically questioned the match review committee’s assessment capabilities, suggesting technological upgrades might be necessary for proper incident evaluation. He advocated for greater understanding toward players’ timing in trial matches and expressed satisfaction with the hearing’s eventual outcome despite his reservations about the process.

With Nathan Cleary now available for selection, the Panthers turn their attention to Friday’s season opener against the Broncos – a rematch of last year’s grand final that ended Penrith’s premiership streak. Cleary dismissed revenge narratives, instead expressing confidence in his squad’s competitive readiness for the 2026 campaign.

‘I feel like we’re going to be really competitive,’ Cleary stated, acknowledging the uncertainty of early season form while maintaining optimism about his team’s championship credentials.