Fresh tensions have emerged between the Israeli government and the Trump administration over a proposed framework to end the months-long Gaza war, with Jerusalem formally conveying its sharp concerns to Washington on Monday while continuing military strikes across the besieged Palestinian territory. This latest disagreement exposes a growing rift between Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and U.S. President Donald Trump, just months before Netanyahu faces a critical reelection contest in October — a race where the Israeli leader has centered his campaign on his close personal and political alliance with the U.S. president, whom he met with just last week.
At the heart of Israel’s objections is the demand for concrete, verifiable full disarmament of the Hamas militant group, which last Friday announced it would surrender its weapons to a newly formed interim Palestinian governing committee under the Trump-backed peace plan. In an official statement to Agence France-Presse, Doron Spielman, spokesperson for Netanyahu’s office, confirmed that Israeli officials had shared their reservations with U.S. counterparts. “The version that has been made public does not reflect Israel’s positions,” Spielman said, adding that Israeli intelligence assessments confirm Hamas has spent the months since the October 2024 ceasefire brokered by Trump actively rearming and recruiting new fighters, in clear preparation for future attacks.
The October ceasefire has reduced the intensity of large-scale conflict, but Israel retains military control over more than 60 percent of the Gaza Strip. According to Gaza’s local authorities, over 1,200 Palestinians have been killed in the territory since the truce took effect. The Israeli military, for its part, has confirmed that five of its soldiers and one civilian contractor have been killed in Gaza during the same period.
Trump framed Hamas’s announcement of weapons surrender as a transformative breakthrough for peace, calling the move a “major milestone” in efforts to end the devastating conflict that began when Hamas launched the deadliest single attack on Israeli soil in the country’s history on October 7, 2023. The U.S. president told reporters Friday that Israel was “very happy” with the development, but Netanyahu has until now remained publicly silent on the plan, breaking that silence only with Monday’s formal transmission of concerns to Washington.
Spielman argued that Hamas’s continued rearming activity proves the group is planning another large-scale attack similar to the October 7 massacre, noting that the Trump administration’s own Board of Peace roadmap outlines a vision for Gaza as “a deradicalised terror-free zone that does not pose a threat to its neighbours”. “That vision stands in direct contrast to the current reality and to Hamas’s stated intentions,” he said. “The indispensable first step toward any lasting arrangement is the genuine, verifiable and irreversible demilitarisation of Hamas. Anything short of full demilitarisation will leave Hamas with the capability to threaten Israel again.”
The four-day-old roadmap released by the Board of Peace calls on Israel to immediately and fully end all military operations in Gaza, and outlines a timeline for a phased Israeli military withdrawal from the territory — terms that run counter to Israel’s long-held position that its forces will remain in Gaza until Hamas’s disarmament is fully completed. This disagreement over the Gaza plan is not the only rift between the two allies: Israel has also openly expressed skepticism over Trump’s diplomatic push to end the brief Iran-Israel war that broke out in late February.
On the ground in Gaza, violence has continued unabated despite the ceasefire agreement. A Gaza-based security official confirmed that Israeli strikes carried out since early Sunday have killed 19 Palestinians, among them multiple women and children. Palestinian authorities added that an Israeli airstrike on Saturday destroyed a large stockpile of critical medical supplies, a loss that exacerbates the already catastrophic humanitarian situation across the strip. Israel has long defended its strikes, stating that Hamas systematically uses civilian infrastructure to hide weapons and fighters, and that Saturday’s strikes targeted two individuals it accuses of planning imminent attacks on Israeli civilians and military personnel.
The growing gap between U.S. and Israeli positions has drawn sharp criticism from senior Palestinian leaders involved in drafting the peace plan. Mohammad Dahlan, a prominent Palestinian political figure who played a central role in negotiating the framework, said that after the roadmap’s release he spoke with Trump’s senior aide and son-in-law Jared Kushner, who initially indicated Israel would end all strikes starting Sunday. Dahlan quickly walked back that claim on social media, revising his statement to say Kushner only confirmed he was “working with the Israeli side to halt the attacks”. Dahlan later accused Netanyahu of actively undermining the best chance to end the devastating conflict. “Netanyahu is working to obstruct the most promising opportunity to begin ending this war,” he said.









