As AFL’s Essendon Bombers navigate a fresh mid-season injury setback, head coach Brad Scott has launched a passionate defense of his under-pressure key defender Ben McKay, hitting out at what he calls unfair and lazy public criticism of the player’s recent form.
McKay came under widespread fire after his underwhelming performance in the high-profile Anzac Day clash against Collingwood. The most heavily criticized moment came when McKay celebrated a spoil that stayed in play, ultimately setting up the Magpies for a match-changing goal. In a media address Wednesday, Scott pushed back against the targeted criticism of McKay, arguing that the 26-year-old defender and the Essendon club as a whole have become easy, convenient punching bags for external commentators.
“I get it’s an easy target. The ability to individualize [externally] is easy, bordering on lazy,” Scott told reporters. “But it’s not him in isolation. We had situations in that game where every player would like moments back.” Scott acknowledged earlier that McKay has not hit his personal best form this season, but added that lapses in confidence are a universal experience for every player competing at the top level of the sport.
“Every player in the competition has, quote-end-quote, confidence issues in their career,” Scott said. “That’s part of being in a cut-throat environment where you’re playing against the very best every week. When you’re a key defender, you play on very good players every week, so you’re right on the edge. Is he just feeling great about himself? Probably not. But does that matter, should that impact your performance? No, it shouldn’t. That’s what we work really hard on: trying to bounce back from difficult situations.” Scott added that McKay’s issue was simply a failure to execute basic fundamentals, not a systemic collapse in form.
Off the back of the debate over McKay, the Bombers received a disappointing injury blow Monday: promising young small forward Isaac Kako has been ruled out of action for at least the next month with a back stress fracture, an injury the club has classified as medium-term. Scott said the club is unable to give a more exact return timeline at this stage, to avoid releasing inaccurate information to fans.
“Medium term is the best we can do at the moment because we don’t want to put something out that’s false,” Scott explained. “The bottom line is that he won’t be playing in the next month or so, at least.” The Essendon coach also highlighted a worrying growing trend of stress fractures in young draftees across the entire AFL league, noting that the injury, traditionally associated with tall, high-impact athletes like 200cm fast bowlers, is now appearing more frequently in smaller players like Kako. Scott added that another Essendon draftee, Sullivan Robey, suffered the same injury before even joining the club’s training program.
“These back stress fractures are unfortunately – not just at our club but across the board – becoming a little bit too common for young players coming into the system,” Scott said. “They’re almost like you expect them in 200cm fast bowlers but not in 180cm small forwards… I think probably the loads on young players prior to the draft is something we would be keen to have a look at.”