A coalition of prominent international intellectuals has issued a forceful challenge to the United Kingdom’s controversial designation of Palestine Action as a terrorist organization. The open letter, published Monday, has garnered signatures from leading leftist thinkers including Tariq Ali, philosopher Judith Butler, and author Naomi Klein.
The letter’s concise but powerful message states: “We oppose genocide, we support the Palestine Action prisoners.” This wording echoes the sentiment expressed by climate activist Greta Thunberg, who was arrested in December for displaying a placard with similar language.
At the heart of the controversy are eight alleged members of Palestine Action currently imprisoned awaiting trial, with two reportedly on hunger strike. These detainees face up to 18 months in custody before their court proceedings begin. Hundreds of additional individuals, predominantly pensioners, have been charged with supporting the organization.
The UK government proscribed Palestine Action under the Terrorism Act of 2000, with then-Home Secretary Yvette Cooper (now Foreign Minister) announcing the ban. The designation makes expressing support for the group’s activities a criminal offense.
The government’s case faced scrutiny during a recent judicial review, where officials presented secret evidence withheld from both the public and the group’s legal representatives to justify the terrorism classification. The ban was ostensibly triggered by a June 2023 incident where activists breached the UK’s largest airbase on electric scooters and damaged two Royal Air Force planes.
International human rights officials, including UN High Commissioner for Human Rights Volker Türk, have criticized the UK’s approach. Türk stated last July that the proscription “appears disproportionate and unnecessary,” noting that it uses anti-terrorism legislation to combat activities that constitute “legitimate exercise of fundamental freedom.” He further warned that the designation limits rights of individuals who “have not themselves engaged in any underlying criminal activity but rather exercised their rights to freedom of expression, peaceful assembly and association.”