In a dramatic legal reversal, Australia’s Victoria Court of Appeal has overturned the murder conviction of former airline pilot Greg Lynn and ordered a retrial for the 2020 death of elderly camper Carol Clay. The court determined that serious procedural irregularities had compromised the original trial, creating a substantial likelihood of justice being miscarried.
The case dates back to March 2020 when Clay, 73, and her boyfriend Russell Hill, 74, vanished from a remote campsite in Victoria’s Wonnangatta Valley, sparking one of the state’s most extensive missing person investigations. Lynn, then 57 and a pilot for Jetstar, was arrested in November 2021 after a lengthy police investigation.
During last year’s five-week trial, prosecutors argued that Lynn had intentionally killed the couple during a confrontation at the campsite. Lynn admitted to moving and burning the bodies and destroying evidence but maintained the deaths resulted from separate accidental struggles over a shotgun and knife. The jury ultimately convicted him of Clay’s murder while acquitting him in Hill’s death, resulting in a 24-year minimum sentence.
The appeal court found multiple breaches of fair trial conduct rules by prosecutors, though specific irregularities weren’t detailed in the public ruling. Court of Appeal President Karin Emerton emphasized the seriousness of the procedural failures in ordering a new trial.
Lynn remains in custody pending his next court appearance scheduled for January 28, where proceedings for the retrial will be formalized. The case has captivated Australian public attention for years, combining elements of mystery, tragedy, and complex legal questions about intent and accidental death in remote wilderness settings.